Galafrey Mt Barker Shiraz 2009 vs Singlefile Frankland River Shiraz 2011

I’m in Shiraz mode today, with a suite of Shiraz and blends open on the bench. 

These two, however, I pulled out to taste separately (single blind) as I thought they would be reasonably similar. In truth they’re so different (and representative of place and maker) that tasting blind was a waste of time…

Galafrey Dry Grown Shiraz 2009 (Mt Barker, WA)
13.5%, Screwcap, $28
Source: Sample

www.galafreywines.com.au

From the 33 year old dry grown estate vineyard, this showcases the hearty rusticity that Galafrey is known for. Sees two years in oak, which oak fortifies the wine a fraction, though this is clearly a big wine regardless – full of spicy black plums, thick purple fruit and black pepper. There’s a nice contrast here of deep, limitless of flavour and a rather, drying meaty finish that all points to low crops and long oak ageing, with an intensity that brings you back every time. Judging by length alone this is a winner, if in a slightly rustic form.

Drink: 2013-2023
Score: 18/20, 93/100
Would I buy it? With something meaty I’d definitely drink a bottle.

Singlefile Frankland Shiraz 2011 (Frankland River, WA)
14.5%, Screwcap, $37
Source: Sample

www.singlefilewines.com

I loved the 2010 version of this wine, as it showed both a swagger and polish that made it very tasty indeed. Following in the trend of a few other 2011 Frankland River reds tasted recently, this Shiraz is an all-together more rounded wine, yet without the same tannic penetration of the 10. If anything it looks too polished, as if it has been over-filtered. Obviously it’s still too young, and there is still an elegant and bright Shiraz under there, but this was just a little disappointing after the 10.

Drink: 2014-2020
Score: 17/20, 90/100
Would I buy it? Not yet.

Andrew Graham Avatar

Andrew Graham was once voted the 23rd most trusted wine critic on the planet. A WCA Journalism Young Gun now old hack with 25yrs as a buyer, judge, journalist, marketer and too much more.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Australian Wine and Drinks Review

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading