A brace of 2010 WA Shiraz: Singlefile + Plantagenet

A brace of WA Shiraz

I’ve been nursing an epic hangover today after an evening out drinking with the Ashmead brothers (of Elderton wines) and a few other likely suspects. It wasn’t the volume of alcohol that really killed me though, it was finishing off a shot of Patron liqueur at 1:30am and then having to get back up at 5am to get a flight back home…

Anyways, I’m bringing myself back into the land of the living tonight with litres of soda water and a look at two very promising WA Shiraz, both of which I liked (for different reasons).

Singlefile Frankland River Shiraz 2010 14.5% $37


The cheaper of these two wines but of a very similar quality level. Different style mind you.

Lots of purple berries – glossy purple/black berries and just a little cabanossi. In other words, cool clime Shiraz a go-go. Mid weight palate is juicy and black fruited, initially quite ripe and round, but also dry and heightened by snappy acidity. What brings you back is the layers of flavour, with a clove and licoricey savoury blackness, topped off with a dry finish and warming alcohol.

I liked this. It’s a more secondary wine than the Plantagenet, likely to drink better younger and be more interesting in the shorter term. Great to see a characterful wine under the Singlefile label too, which has taken a while to produce genuinely interesting wines. 18.5/20, 94/100

Plantagenet Mt Barker Shiraz 2010 14.1% $45.95
A rather more oak-rich and opulent Shiraz compared to the Singlefile, yet also a somewhat deeper wine too. More HB pencil oak, purple texta and a palate that is less wild and a little more direct purple fruit.There is a lovely mid palate sweetness to this, a wine that is less about extract and meat and more about texture and palate weight. You just know that in time it’s going to be a lovely round and silken, purple fruit-rich,  mid-weight red. Very nice. 18.3/20, 93/100
Ultimately I find myself drawn to the meaty dark heart of the Singlefile in this lineup, but both have an immediately attractive, licoricey modern style. Both recommended methinks.
Andrew Graham Avatar

Andrew Graham was once voted the 23rd most trusted wine critic on the planet. A WCA Journalism Young Gun now old hack with 25yrs as a buyer, judge, journalist, marketer and too much more.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Australian Wine and Drinks Review

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading